> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://themountainnarrative.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Strange Business of Collecting Mountains
- URL: https://themountainnarrative.com/the-strange-business-of-collecting-mountains/
- Published: 2026-11-20T08:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-20T08:00:00.000Z
- Description: From Scotland’s Munros to the Seven Summits, Malaysia’s mountain graduates and Indonesia’s inventive hiking challenges, a look at humanity’s peculiar habit of collecting mountains — and why finishing one list is rarely enough.
- Author: The Mountain Narrative
- Tags: Features, Culture, History

*From Scotland's Munros to the Seven Summits, Malaysia's mountain graduates and Indonesia's wonderfully inventive hiking challenges, humans have developed a peculiar habit of turning mountains into collections. And finishing one list rarely seems to be enough.*

In 1891, Sir Hugh Munro published a [list of Scotland's mountains exceeding 3,000 feet](https://www.mountaineering.scot/activities/hillwalking/munros-and-corbetts/the-munros?ref=themountainnarrative.com). It was a remarkable undertaking for its time, an attempt to catalogue the country's higher mountains using the geographical information then available. His original tables identified 283 separate mountains, providing future generations of hillwalkers with something they hadn't necessarily realised they needed: a checklist.

What began as a geographical exercise gradually became a national pastime. People started climbing the mountains on Munro's list, keeping records of their progress and setting out to complete the entire collection. The mountains became known as Munros, the activity as *Munro-bagging*, and those who successfully climbed them all acquired the rather wonderful title of *compleaters*.

The list has evolved over the years. Improved surveying techniques and revisions to mountain classifications have reduced the official number to 282, while generations of walkers have continued to pursue the challenge. For some, completing the Munros is a lifelong ambition; for others, it is the beginning of an enduring relationship with the Scottish Highlands.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/4d/55/4d55487e-b0b0-47be-b50d-ae948550038f/content/images/2026/11/1280px-View_southwest_from_Ben_Lawers-_Scottish_Highlands-_Scotland.jpg)

Looking towards Meall Corranaich and Meall nan Tarmachan from Ben Lawers, Scotland. Photograph: Michal Klajban / Wikimedia Commons.

There is, however, a particularly delightful detail about the man who started it all.

When Munro died in 1919, he had three mountains remaining on his own list. The Reverend A. E. Robertson had already become the first recorded Munro compleater in 1901, but Munro himself never quite managed to finish the collection that would eventually bear his name.

Perhaps that makes him the most relatable peak-bagger of all. Even the man who made the list never quite got around to finishing it.

## Seven Summits. Eight Mountains.

The appeal of collecting mountains was never likely to remain confined to Scotland. As mountaineering developed, so did the ambition to organise increasingly grand collections. Some were defined by elevation, others by geography, and a few would eventually become among the most recognisable challenges in the sport.

The Seven Summits offered a particularly elegant proposition: climb the highest mountain on each of the world's seven continents. It was simple enough to explain, sufficiently difficult to command respect, and ambitious enough to attract mountaineers willing to devote years of their lives to completing it.

In 1985, American businessman and mountaineer [Dick Bass became the first person to complete the challenge](https://publications.americanalpineclub.org/articles/12199512700/The-Seven-Summits?ref=themountainnarrative.com), finishing with an ascent of Mount Everest. His achievement helped bring the Seven Summits into international prominence, establishing a collection that would inspire generations of climbers.

There was just one complication. Not everyone agreed on which seven mountains counted.

Bass's list included Mount Kosciuszko, the highest mountain on the Australian mainland. Reinhold Messner, however, advocated a different interpretation, favouring Puncak Jaya, also known as Carstensz Pyramid, in Indonesian Papua. The disagreement centred on whether the relevant geographical region should be understood as Australia or the broader region of Australasia or Oceania, which includes New Guinea.

For anyone attempting the challenge, this was more than an academic distinction. Kosciuszko, at 2,228 metres, is accessible by established walking routes and is commonly climbed as a day hike. Puncak Jaya, rising to approximately 4,884 metres, is a technical limestone peak involving exposed climbing, remote access and far more complicated expedition logistics.

The difference between the two interpretations was therefore considerable. One version of the Seven Summits required a walk to Australia's highest point; the other demanded a technical expedition to a remote mountain in Papua.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/4d/55/4d55487e-b0b0-47be-b50d-ae948550038f/content/images/2026/11/1280px-Seven_Summits_Infographic_-en-.svg.webp)

The Seven Summits compared by elevation, including Puncak Jaya and Mount Kosciuszko, the competing choices in the Bass and Messner lists. Illustration: GilPe / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0\. [https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/?ref=themountainnarrative.com)

Canadian mountaineer [Pat Morrow eventually offered a rather practical solution](https://alpineclubofcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/SS12-%E2%80%93-Morrow.pdf?ref=themountainnarrative.com). On 5 August 1986, he became the first person to complete both versions of the Seven Summits. Having already climbed Kosciuszko and Puncak Jaya, he finished the combined collection with an ascent of Mount Elbrus. What began as a seven-mountain challenge had somehow acquired an eighth.

There is something wonderfully characteristic of mountaineering about this outcome. Faced with a disagreement over which mountain belonged on the list, the solution was not necessarily to settle the geographical argument, but to climb another mountain.

The Seven Summits was hardly the last collection to inspire such ambition. At the more extreme end of the sport lies the challenge of climbing all fourteen of the world's mountains exceeding 8,000 metres, an achievement historically associated with Reinhold Messner's completion in 1986\. Unlike the geographical disagreement surrounding the Seven Summits, this collection has a clear numerical threshold. The challenge, of course, lies in actually climbing fourteen of the highest mountains on Earth.

As mountain collections grew in scale and ambition, they acquired records, rivalries and increasingly elaborate definitions of success. But elsewhere, hiking communities were developing their own traditions, often with rules that were considerably less complicated.

## Congratulations, You've Graduated

In Peninsular Malaysia, collecting mountains has developed something resembling an educational system.

[The country's G7 challenge](https://worldmeasure.com/mountains/malaysia?ref=themountainnarrative.com) comprises seven mountains exceeding 7,000 feet: Gunung Tahan, Korbu, Yong Belar, Gayong, Chamah, Yong Yap and Ulu Sepat. Together, they represent some of the most demanding trekking objectives in Peninsular Malaysia, where dense tropical rainforest, steep terrain and prolonged exposure to humidity can turn even relatively modest elevations into serious undertakings.

Unlike the Seven Summits, the G7 does not involve crossing continents or travelling to the world's highest mountain ranges. Yet the challenges are considerable in their own right. Remote approaches, muddy ridgelines, river crossings and multi-day journeys through thick jungle demand endurance, preparation and a willingness to remain uncomfortable for extended periods.

Altitude alone rarely tells the full story of a mountain. A 2,000-metre peak in a tropical rainforest can present an entirely different experience from a similarly elevated mountain reached by a well-maintained alpine trail. In Malaysia, the difficulty often lies not in thin air or technical climbing, but in the relentless nature of the terrain and the conditions encountered along the way.

Within the local hiking community, completing all seven mountains is sometimes described as *graduating* from G7\. The terminology has an appealing logic. The challenge can take years to finish, requires a considerable amount of preparation, and comes with a sense of accomplishment recognised by others who have undertaken the same journey.

The practical examinations, admittedly, involve rather more mud and considerably fewer desks than most university courses.

And as with conventional education, graduation does not necessarily mark the end of one's studies.

Beyond the G7 lies the G11, an expanded collection that adds Gunung Batu Putih, Irau, Benum and Gerah. These additional mountains bring the total to eleven, offering hikers who have already completed the original challenge another objective to pursue.

Evidently, mountaineering has postgraduate programmes too.

The attraction is not difficult to understand. A collection such as the G7 provides structure to an activity that might otherwise consist of unrelated weekend adventures. Each completed mountain becomes part of a larger undertaking, and the shared objective creates a sense of community among hikers who may take very different paths towards the same goal.

The graduation terminology also captures something important about how these challenges are experienced. Completing a collection is not merely about reaching seven summits. It represents the accumulation of experience across different mountains, conditions and expeditions.

Of course, a certificate of graduation does not mean someone has mastered every aspect of mountaineering. But it does provide a memorable way to recognise a substantial personal achievement.

And for those who find themselves wondering what comes after G11, the wider world of mountain collecting offers no shortage of possibilities.

## Indonesia: When Three Is the Magic Number

Indonesia has taken the business of collecting mountains in several interesting directions.

Its best-known national collection is the [Indonesian Seven Summits](https://indonesiabaik.id/infografis/seven-summits-indonesia?ref=themountainnarrative.com), a challenge spanning seven major mountains across the archipelago: Kerinci in Sumatra, Semeru in Java, Rinjani in the Lesser Sunda Islands, Bukit Raya in Kalimantan, Rantemario, the highest summit of the Latimojong range in Sulawesi, Binaiya in Maluku and Puncak Jaya in Papua.

It is a collection defined as much by the extraordinary geographical diversity of Indonesia as by the mountains themselves. Completing it involves travelling across an immense archipelago, encountering different climates and landscapes, and progressing from volcanic trekking to the technical demands of Puncak Jaya.

But not every mountain challenge needs to involve seven summits, multiple islands or an elaborate geographical classification.

Within local hiking communities, informal combinations such as 3S and 3U offer a more playful approach. These are community-created challenges rather than official or universally standardised mountaineering classifications, and their appeal lies partly in how easily they can turn a handful of familiar destinations into a shared objective.

The **3S** brings together Sindoro, Sumbing and Slamet, three prominent Central Javanese volcanoes whose names begin with the letter S. Their proximity makes them an appealing combination for hikers looking to complete several substantial climbs within the same region.

The **3U** follows a similar principle, although with a slightly different rule. Prau, Merbabu and Lawu are grouped together because their names end with the letter U.

There is no complicated elevation threshold to satisfy, no continental boundary to debate and no need to determine which mountain is technically the highest in a particular region. Sometimes, three mountains sharing a letter are enough to create a challenge.

Another informal combination takes the idea even further: **3R**, grouping Raung, Rinjani and Ranu Kumbolo.

Raung is an imposing East Javanese volcano, known for its demanding summit terrain and exposed sections along the crater rim. Rinjani, on Lombok, is one of Indonesia's most recognisable trekking destinations, with its immense volcanic landscape and celebrated crater lake.

Ranu Kumbolo, meanwhile, is a beautiful high-altitude lake along the trekking route towards Mount Semeru.

Yes, a lake.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/4d/55/4d55487e-b0b0-47be-b50d-ae948550038f/content/images/2026/11/IMG_7877.jpg)

Ranu Kumbolo, a mountain lake along the trekking route to Mount Semeru in East Java, Indonesia. Photograph © The Mountain Narrative.

Not a mountain, not a subsidiary peak, and certainly not a summit. Somewhere along the way, the business of collecting mountains has become flexible enough to include a body of water.

Yet there is something rather appealing about these informal challenges. They do not require an international organisation to establish their rules or a formal record-keeping system to validate their completion. They emerge from the interests of hiking communities, giving friends another reason to organise a trip, revisit familiar landscapes or explore mountains they might otherwise have overlooked.

And while the names may sound playful, the journeys themselves need not be easy. Climbing Sindoro, Sumbing and Slamet still involves three substantial volcanic ascents. Raung and Rinjani remain serious mountain objectives regardless of how creatively they are grouped together.

The collection may be invented, but the effort required to complete it is very real.

In a country with hundreds of volcanoes and an enormous variety of mountain landscapes, the possibilities for creating new combinations are practically endless. A challenge can be based on geography, elevation, volcanic characteristics, shared letters or simply a memorable idea that catches on among friends.

If Scotland gave the world a formal catalogue of mountains to complete, Indonesia demonstrates how enthusiastically the concept can be adapted when hikers are free to make up their own rules.

## The Trouble With Finishing

For all their peculiarities, mountain collections serve a surprisingly practical purpose. They give shape to an activity that might otherwise have no obvious endpoint.

A person can spend a lifetime climbing mountains without ever needing a list. But a collection provides direction, turning individual trips into a longer undertaking. It encourages people to explore unfamiliar places, return to regions they might otherwise have left behind and pursue objectives that require patience over months or years.

It also creates a shared language. Scottish hillwalkers understand what it means to be a Munro compleater. Malaysian hikers recognise the significance of graduating from G7\. Indonesian hiking communities can turn a simple abbreviation into an itinerary, a challenge and eventually a story worth telling.

None of this diminishes the individual mountains. The weather on a Scottish ridge is no more forgiving because the summit appears on a checklist. The jungles of Peninsular Malaysia do not become easier because someone is approaching graduation. And the exposed terrain of Raung remains just as consequential whether it is climbed independently or as part of an informal collection.

The rules may be human inventions, but the mountains remain entirely real.

Perhaps the strangest part of mountain collecting is what happens when the collection is finally complete. After years of planning, travelling and climbing, the last summit is reached, the final mountain is ticked off, and the objective that once seemed so distant is suddenly finished.

For some, that may be enough. Others will inevitably begin looking for another challenge.

After all, Sir Hugh Munro left three mountains unfinished, Pat Morrow climbed eight to complete a challenge of seven, and Malaysian hikers have found a way to continue their education long after graduation.

And somewhere in Indonesia, someone is probably working out which three mountains share another letter.

## Sources & References

1. Mountaineering Scotland — *The Munros*  
[https://www.mountaineering.scot/activities/hillwalking/munros-and-corbetts/the-munros](https://www.mountaineering.scot/activities/hillwalking/munros-and-corbetts/the-munros?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
2. National Trust for Scotland — *A Guide to Munro-bagging*  
[https://www.nts.org.uk/visit/things-to-do/a-guide-to-munro-bagging](https://www.nts.org.uk/visit/things-to-do/a-guide-to-munro-bagging?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
3. American Alpine Club — *The Seven Summits*  
[https://publications.americanalpineclub.org/articles/12199512700/The-Seven-Summits](https://publications.americanalpineclub.org/articles/12199512700/The-Seven-Summits?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
4. Alpine Club of Canada — *Pat Morrow Profile*  
[https://alpineclubofcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/SS12-%E2%80%93-Morrow.pdf](https://alpineclubofcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/SS12-%E2%80%93-Morrow.pdf?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
5. Seven Summits — *Our Story*  
[https://www.sevensummits.com/our-story](https://www.sevensummits.com/our-story?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
6. World Measure — *Mountains of Malaysia*  
[https://worldmeasure.com/mountains/malaysia](https://worldmeasure.com/mountains/malaysia?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
7. The Seven Summits of Indonesia — *Official Website*  
[https://the7summitsindonesia.com/](https://the7summitsindonesia.com/?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
8. Indonesia Baik — *Seven Summits Indonesia*  
[https://indonesiabaik.id/infografis/seven-summits-indonesia](https://indonesiabaik.id/infografis/seven-summits-indonesia?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
9. SGTREK — *Gunung 3S Challenge Indonesia (2023)*  
[https://sgtrek.com/event/gunung-3s-challenge-indonesia-2023/](https://sgtrek.com/event/gunung-3s-challenge-indonesia-2023/?ref=themountainnarrative.com)
10. IDN Times — *Mengenal Gunung 3U di Jawa Tengah*  
[https://www.idntimes.com/travel/destination/mengenal-gunung-3u-di-jawa-tengah-c1c2-01-6n9g9-rfwgn8/amp](https://www.idntimes.com/travel/destination/mengenal-gunung-3u-di-jawa-tengah-c1c2-01-6n9g9-rfwgn8/amp?ref=themountainnarrative.com)